Securly is Watching You
But is it effective at all?
October 25, 2018
I am not Catholic, and today is not a Sunday, but I have a confession.
The first time that I can remember being in actual trouble was when I almost got run over by a car while playing soccer in the road. Having been told repeatedly not to play in the street, my parents decided it was time for punishment harsher than reprimanding words: I was not allowed to play soccer for a week, either at home or at school. Needless to say, I went to school the next day and, as soon as the recess bell rang, grabbed a soccer ball. Sorry, Mom.
The point of my confession isnāt to toot my own rebellious horn or to relieve myself of a lingering moral weight upon my shoulders. Its purpose is instead to show that as long as there are restrictions, kids will find a way around themāand yes, this isnāt necessarily always a good thing. Teenagers, myself included, are often idiots and need at least a loose set of rules to follow. However, acknowledging the difference between guiding and strangling is imperative.
I believe the administration needs to acknowledge the difference between guiding and strangling. For a while, students haveĀ been forced to put up with Securly, a censoring application. Obviously, this isnāt news. However, the blatant disregard for student privacy is.
Parents of NA students recently received an email offering a service that would allow them to monitor their children’s use of laptops, iPads, or other school technology. To a certain extent, it isnāt a bad idea, especially for the younger grades. It allows for a simple way for parents to check for appropriate usage of technology. For example, if a 4th grader is meant to have spent two hours practicing on Rocket Math, but was instead watching Fortnite dance compilations, his parents would know.
That being said, the same cannot apply to high schoolers, as the presence of phones and VPNs completely counteracts the goals behind this privacy-encroaching initiative that was implemented to restrict inappropriate internet usage and attempt to hold student attention.Ā However, students most likely would not use their school-issued laptops to conduct āillicitā searches. If students want to view sites that include pornography, violence, or otherwise inappropriate content, they will simply use their phones.
And yes, I am aware that policing content is certainly the more secondary inspiration behind offering the Securly service. The main concern is making sure students pay attention during class. While this is an admirable aspiration, it is certainly not feasible to maintain student focus on a scale that the administration wants.Ā The issue of students neglecting to pay attention predatesĀ computers by many, many years. Our parents werenāt forced to pay attention because of their lack of technology, and we will not be forced to pay attention with Securly and constant monitoring of our internet usage.Ā
Bringing this back to my initial introduction, I want to mention the other reason why Securly will not work: Virtual Private Networks, or āVPNs.ā Since the introduction of school provided laptops and iPads, the IT department has been restricting studentsā ability to use VPNs, which give students access to restricted websites and disable the monitoring system that Securely leverages. Despite the administration’s best efforts to eliminate VPNs, they continue to struggle. To be fair, however, admin accounts, flash drive boots, and other work-arounds make full monitoring almost impossible, at least without a substantial resource commitment.
So, if the effects of Securly can be entirely negated, and are likely to have a minimal effect on whether students actually pay attention, I ask the administration this: why implement it at all? Why not trust us insteadāas you do with cars, phones, borrowed books, and general safetyāand believe that we will do what is right?Ā
Anh Nguyen • Aug 22, 2024 at 5:43 pm
Hey, LOVE the article, I have been having to put up with securly for 2 – 3 years, and I think IT has just let securly off the leash, kids and my friends at my school are getting fed up with it, but no one wants to say anything about it because if someone does, the administrator might find out, and we get yelled at for complaining (btw, I go to MHS-Mentor High School-which gets fights as early as 7 or 8 in the morning.) There is now even an update in Google Docs where teachers can see what we are typing in real-time.
Henry • Mar 26, 2024 at 4:35 pm
Securly actually has been causing lag on student chromebooks. Me and my friend’s chromebooks have been getting slower and slower, and our chromebooks weren’t this slow before Securly. Also, securly doesn’t protect any of the sites that are actually harmful, so my classmates are still managing to find inappropriate content and students still get computer viruses.
Jack • Jan 6, 2024 at 5:57 pm
As a middle school student at a school that doesn’t allow phones, I despise securly. It blocks everything, even if it isn’t inappropriate. Sometimes it even blocks things the teacher tells us to do. Securly is a sick and despicable way of schools restricting and spying on kids. Even if it’s distracting, why punish the entire school because one student decided not to do schoolwork? This system is twisted to the point that many middle schoolers have coded their own exploits to get past this extension. I think securly should only be allowed for people who have done things in class more than 50 times. This is the most awful thing that schools have invented in a long time.
Gentry N. • Nov 28, 2023 at 10:31 pm
This is a great article about the overpowering dictator that is securly. I am a middle school student that is constantly watched from securly everyday, and I hardly ever search up something off topic at school. I’ve noticed that when I am doing research for an assignment, it starts to randomly block people, events, historical sites, and more. Last year, there was a mini crisis going on in my district where the only thing securly allowed was google apps like docs and slides. It is definitely a screwed up security app and does more harm than good.
Samuel • Sep 5, 2023 at 8:38 pm
Awesome work. I feel like it’s true that the school needs to restrict us somewhat, but not to the point that they’re scanning our personal emails and passwords. What they think is helping us is really driving us insane.
AGNAB • Sep 21, 2022 at 2:24 pm
Incredible article, very well written. I agree completely! I feel it isn’t very logical for them to trust us with other things like phones, cars, books, etc. but still won’t trust us with our Chromebooks.
memeGokusan • May 18, 2021 at 9:07 am
Great article dude, in my opinion Securly was built so it can make students as upset as possible, i would read a bunch of reviews and there was this one PDF (made by securly) where Kids thought what should be unblocked, and as far as i know that never happened, They Showed Positive reviews and negative reviews but never talked about the negative ones after just the positive ones. to a certain extent securly is alright it would be a helpful site if it didnt block an entire search just cuz you typed in the word Drug. kids need to search that up because its for an assignment, even my teachers are gettin mad at the Blocker, Yesterday my TEACHER (thats right a teacher) made a video on how to get past blocks on securly, that should be sendin off Red flags to my administrator, if teachers are starting to help kids unblock stuff, i think it’s time to either cut securly off and get a new blocker or figure out a way to Limit how much is blocked on our chromebooks
Lex Gall • Nov 16, 2023 at 10:58 am
nah, that teacher is just a legend
Blake • Apr 21, 2021 at 3:49 pm
I am not comfortable with the fact that teachers know every little thing we do. Like if we even move the mouse, it knows I did it.The other day I watched a mine craft video on YouTube after school. The next day I went to school, and my teacher said, “why did you watch that mine craft video at school?” and humiliated me in front of the whole class. Securly was probably created by some really overprotective mom who hates kids happiness. BTW, loved that article! I am in 5th grade, And it blocks all things good and holy, such as: cool math games? blocked. PBS kids? Blocked. Duckduckgo? Blocked. Omegle? Unblocked games? NOT BLOCKED!
MooMan M. • Jan 22, 2021 at 4:26 pm
I love this article… I hate securly, and I am trying to find as many ways to bypass it as possible. As a student, I think they are just trying to make school feel as miserable as possible, at least that how makes me feel. I can never do anything that has something blocked by securly. Even when it does not have to do with video games.
ORCA41 • Jan 6, 2021 at 11:53 am
I HATE SECURELY!!! I think that it is okay to block harmful things, but the administration is just going overboard!!! I’m in 7th grade, and I was doing a research project on Dr. Michael Bigg, whose research ended killer whale capture in the Salish sea. Go back. KILLER WHALE RESEARCH. Of course since all of the articles about him have KILLER in them because of KILLER WHALES it wouldnt let me research him. The administration is going completely overboard blocking too many things that instead of helping us students to focus, it is instead getting in the way of our learning.
Jeb Dedulsko • Dec 21, 2020 at 9:51 am
We have securly being used at our school. Not just the blocking type– the type where teachers literally SPY ON YOU TOO! Yes, yes, teachers, I GET that just ONE person in our ENTIRE class watches YouTube during class. Well, I don’t think they noticed that the rest of us are perfectly good. Why else would they be watching us and closing our tabs? Do they just want to annoy us? Tell us off for doing homework? They completely closed one of my homework tabs one time, and NOT A THING SAVED! Securly is horrible!
Sanjar • Nov 28, 2020 at 10:21 pm
Securly is Terrible It blocks everything
Alyssa Wescott • Oct 18, 2020 at 12:32 pm
Oh my gosh. Securly just added “Restricted Mode”, but it isn’t really Restricted Mode. You can’t turn it off. When I try to watch some Youtube videos when I’m done with homework, or for actual school, it blocks many and says to “join with a G Suite account”. There have been rumors that Securly can watch you through the camera of your device, so I suggest putting a sticker on yours if you believe in that. Securly seems like it wasn’t actually meant to help keep safety. It seems like it was meant to torture students and making them frustrated.
Braden Murphy • Oct 16, 2020 at 7:20 am
bruh, good article bro, we used to use Forticlient in my middle school but it broke so we went to securly. all the things we want to go on are blocked, even for teachers. It is blocking educational websittes. (nearpod, flocabulary, classkick, gimkit, kahoot, quizziz, etc) and unblocked youtube for kids the other day. many would be happy about this but it is techically a threat to students. things like twitter insta and snapchat are all unblocked and a kid showed the entire school that “omegle” was unb;ocked (i was told a website normally filled to the brim with predators)
cant say • Oct 13, 2020 at 2:37 pm
theres a petition on care2 petitions to end securly. 900 out of 1000 signings.
Alyssa Wescott • Sep 30, 2020 at 11:19 am
I’m only in 5th grade and my district installed Securly. It never helped me and it blocked many websites that my teachers needed to follow. Whenever I look up innocent images and go to images, it shows skulls, people in shadows, and many disturbing images that make me weirded out and creeped out. I hate Securly and I want to get rid of it, but my administrator won’t. Seeing this article makes me feel more hopeful that Securly will be stopped.
Evan S****** • Sep 4, 2020 at 1:11 pm
Securly is a hot dumpster fire. I just wanna go to the most HARMLESS sites and guess what? They’re blocked.
Jacob Sillinger • Aug 3, 2020 at 10:04 pm
Thank you for making this, just today youtube got banned for BLACKLISTING! So now also my professors can’t show us videos. I hope it goes bankrupt.
Lyla G****** • May 15, 2020 at 12:03 pm
AHHHHHHHH!!! There are soooo many websites I would love to use, CoolMathGames, etc. But they’re all blocked. Securly is trying to protect you from harmful websites, but I think it’s just eliminating websites from students and other people. This is so infuriating. I am 12 and in 6th grade, and this is all I have to say:
OMG SECURLY STOP ELIMINATING OUR FUN AND ENJOYMENT FOR SCHOOL AND FREE TIME!!!
I vote a 1/10 for Securly. š
Mars Jackson • Mar 15, 2020 at 12:21 pm
I’m stuck using a school Chromebook for work, but securly blocks everything I need to use (even google classroom on occasion) and the only way to even try to get past it is using a new browser app a few friends and I found. But I’m not sure how long that is going to last though…
Plus, a lot of the admin and IT at my school hate securly, and are talking to the top people about getting it removed. It’s stupid, it’s taking away the privacy I need as an young adult from my parents, and it just doesn’t work.
Ali Glass • Jan 13, 2020 at 1:17 pm
Why does Securly exist? it sucks and it shouldn’t be a thing and you can get around it with proxy and hot spots
Jacob • Dec 11, 2019 at 9:02 pm
I hate Securly. There was this awesome game that the whole school played called āTileMan.ioā then just today it just got blocked. It had nothing to do with anything bad. The bad thing is that I donāt have a phone, so I canāt just use my phone. I have to use the school IPad. Me and my friends are trying to find a way to take Securly of our iPads. Then just at the end of the day a student in my class figured it out. I am still learning how.
A student • Sep 9, 2019 at 11:35 am
It’s beautiful. this article is a masterpiece. Thank you so, so, so, so much for creating this piece of genius! It’s the first step of my act against securly. I can’t thank
you enough.
forrest • Aug 30, 2019 at 1:57 am
they blocked the web extension ecosia, the one that plants trees. uncool, inconsiderate and closed minded.
anthony • Jun 8, 2019 at 6:57 pm
hello from virginia cool article man! more power to us students! Also, can you really run linux from a hard drive?
austin • May 21, 2019 at 12:51 pm
amen to that great article securly blocks unnecessary things and it is a shame. if someone searches something illegal it will be caught by a tech department guy at the least so why even implement securly it encourages dumb people to hide their inappropriate searches.
Charlie • May 10, 2019 at 11:35 am
securly sucks did you know it made you less protected against viruses? yeah,i know.
Chris • Jan 14, 2019 at 12:17 pm
Originally we did not use securly, but the continued use of VPN’s to watch explicit content my school administration came to securly as a last hope.