Marvel and DC represent the two largest American comic universes, and are often heavily compared and debated among fans. Both studios are distinct, as they have their own charms and appeal. In turn, there is also no surprise why the debates between both sides have been consistently heated in pop culture.

In a poll, 20 NASH students and teachers were asked whether they preferred DC or Marvel. Marvel edged out DC with 11 votes to 9. 

Historically, DC has held a strong position when it comes to comic sales and iconic characters, but with the success of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) since 2008, Marvel has gained a lead in popularity. 

However, probably the biggest point of comparison between the two universes is the characters. Both have some very iconic characters that are often used in debate to argue which universe is better. 

Starting with legacy characters–characters who inherit, share, or succeed established superhero identities. Some examples of legacy characters in DC are Barry Allen (who succeeded Jay Garrick as the Flash) Hal Jordan (who succeeded Alan Scott as Green Lantern) and Jaime Reyes (who succeeded Dan Garrett and Ted Kord as Blue Beetle). All of these legacy characters are considered more popular than their predecessors. 

DC has many more legacies–in fact, it is something they are known for– like Batman’s sidekick Robin and Superman.

Robin started with Dick Grayson, who shed the mantle and became the vigilante Nightwing. It was then passed to Jason Todd, who ended up becoming the crime lord Red Hood. Next, it moved to Tim Drake–who is widely acknowledged for having the potential to surpass Batman in detective skills–and he is now Red Robin. There are many more who have held this mantle.

While Marvel also has some very recognizable legacy characters, like Sam Wilson as Captain America and Kate Bishop as Hawkeye, it can be argued that DC’s legacy characters are much more iconic. 

Moving past legacy characters, and onto general superheroes from both universes, there are often heated debates among fans whether DC or Marvel has stronger characters. It seems Marvel focuses on “human” characters with relatable flaws, while DC often centers on mythological, “god-like” figures. For example, Captain America is an enhanced war hero, while Superman is an alien from space. Iron man is a genius billionaire who uses technology to improve his abilities, while Batman is a billionaire polymath who is on par with superman despite his lack of powers. 

Marvel characters often get their abilities due to experimentation, an unfortunate incident, or their own incredible intelligence, while DC character’s origins are usually much more fantastical. 

DC is an escape from reality, while Marvel is a reflection of it–and a reminder that you are not alone. 

There is often a discussion over who the faces of the “Superhero Mount Rushmore” are. It is mostly agreed that the four heroes that belong up there are Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, and Spiderman. While many people make an argument for Iron Man or Captain America, they have only gained popularity fairly recently due to the MCU, and the four have been relevant since the beginning. 

Spiderman is arguably the most popular superhero of modern day, his relatability and age appealing to a lot of Gen Z, and many finding relief in his comedic personality. Peter Parker faces common challenges like financial pressure and bullying, making him more accessible than untouchable billionaire or alien heroes. 

While DC is so enjoyable, it lacks what Marvel has when it comes to relatability and humanity, and Marvel lacks DC’s storytelling and community. 

Between the two, Marvel has better movies–though DC seems to be catching up in that aspect–and DC has better comics and characters.